Most overrated developer?

[Curmudgeon]

CGI-Quality said:

DexInDaJungle said:
I don't think some people in this thread understand that one can be great while still being overrated.

Anyway, I have to say Nintendo. Love them but there is a certain crowd, especially critics who simply have a hard on for anything Nintendo produces. While I agree the quality is there most of the time, I simply wouldn't call every game a master piece.

As for Naughty Dog, I can see why some people would call them overrated. Believe it or not, some people care very little for story telling in video games and look more for unique gameplay which something like Uncharted lacks imho.

You don't have to add unique gameplay to your games for them to be great. Furthermore, that's hardly a reason a company should considered "overrated", especially when their specialties are character, storytelling, and technical achivements - things they generally excel at. 

I see your point, but honestly I think their character and storytelling are mediocre (technical achievements I agree with you). I think they were much better during PS1/PS2 days (Crash, Jak, I love those games) than they are now.