By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
kowenicki said:

Sterling isnt their currency to keep, (Bank of England has already said "no chance").  They would have to apply to join the Euro and they would fail every economic test to do so.

Not true on both counts. The Bank of England has not said 'no chance', only politicians have done that. It isn't the Bank of England's decision, after all. Mark Carney did say that he believed some sovereign powers would have to be relinquished if Scotland were to join a currency union, something the SNP, of course, denied would have to be the case. This Guardian article nicely sums that debate up (and is a useful reference as the article originally falsely claimed the Mark Carney claimed a currency union would be 'unworkable', but was edited later): Clicky click

As for the Euro: there is nobody seriously saying Scotland 'would have to apply' to join the Euro. The Euro is not currently on the table at all.

kowenicki said:

If they do vote yes then at least as an Englishman I will get MY independence back. 

I'm interested to read why you think that.

kowenicki said:

Seriously. Turkeys dont vote for Christmas unless they are very, very stupid... it will be a NO vote.

The first half is extraordinarily offensive. The second half, though, I do agree with, it will likely be a no vote.