I don't agree with #1 but I can see why they picked it I guess. Just happy they put GTA5 above SA (hate SA and it was my least favorite of all 3d GTAs including the PSP ones). Oh boy...Heavy Rain above Mario Galaxy 2? The hate is going to be strong in this thread. I actually have a WiiU and have played all the 3d Marios and everything and I would put them right together but I know 3d Mario is for some reason put on a pedestal. Personally I think nostalgia effects metacritics for many Nintendo games and I'm glad this publication seems to be unbiased in that regard while still having appreciation for the classics that those games truly are.