Enslaved: Odyssey to the West could be you #13, one of the most underrated games of the decade.
To be honest, I'm surprised that has a low/mid 80's metacritic (unless you're referring to the PC version that got slammed).
Some of mine:
-Warhawk (this was seriously the first 9.0+ system seller-worthy PS3 exclusive to me)
-blah blah blah
(Sea of Solitude Review)