Some of the games I remember enjoying in spite of their bad reviews:
PlayStation Move Ape Escape (PS3) - 43 metacritic
Racquet Sports (PS3) - 45 metacritic
Duke Nukem Forever (PS3) - 51 metacritic
Need for Speed Undercover (PS3) - 59 metacritic
And of course one of my favorite games Time Commando released on PC and PS1 in 1996. Am I the only one who played and loved this game?