DF: In Theory: Can Xbox One multi-platform games compete with PlayStation 4?

[Scoobes]

walsufnir said:

Scoobes said:
The comparative tests carried out in the article feel incomplete. He's only looking at a few aspects of the chips and not taking into accounts factors like the number of ROPs in the two chips and doesn't really go into anywhere near enough detail about the memory bandwidth.

Personally I think it's be better if they continued this with more comparisons that take each of these variables into account.

 

Therefore they say "in theory". I think they still did a good approach to the complicated topic it is. I think it's ok the way it is and now I am looking forward to see comparisons of real games. Fifa 2k14, Battlefield, COD, I am waiting for you! :)

Even "in theory" it's incomplete. It's taking a full picture based on only a single aspect of the GPUs. There are currently too many variables and assumptions in the article for anything meaningul to be gleaned. It's like like the story of the blind man and the elephant.

Personally I think this should be part 1 of a series of articles comparing the hardware. As it is it feels a bit rushed and needs more tests.