I gave it a 95 on my games collection and I still think that makes sense.
Its story was perfect. Its gameplay was perfect. Its challenges was perfect. Its Zeld-esque style was perfect. Its ending was perfect (love the throw backs). Its art-style was amazing. Its controls were really good.
Basically, my only issue is the controls and that's a relatively minor issue.
1. They should have used IR for menu system. That alone would have nearly perfected it.
2. There were many times I know I moved a certain way but it recognized something else. This may be my fault or game's understanding... but it did give some issues in major boss fights.
Basically, had those two items been rectified, I would have given it a nearly perfect score as there is always room for improvement. :)