By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
rocketpig said:
 

I expect a Game of the Year (in some peoples' eyes here) to offer some new and intriguing gameplay or story, that's all.

Uncharted doesn't offer that.

I'll never understand that. Innovation is something that only comes 1-5 per generation. You can't possibly expect innovation in every great game that comes out. There has not been a single innovative game this generation.