It seems he's bugged by Uncharted 2's higher Meta. As ridiculous as it is, it does have a certain merit though: Uncharted 2 doesn't have the same amount of content, as robust as an online, and no creation mode. That doesn't necessarily mean that all that makes Reach the better package, but the heftier one. Still doesn't mean it deserves higher scores than (as you put it) the PS3's darling either.
What I'm saying to you, Dirty, just be happy with Reach. HEAVY RAIN's Meta is nearly 10 points lower than Uncharted 2's. Which of the two would I play and enjoy more?
To be fair though when uncharted 3 comes out you'll see the same thing from fans of that series too. I guarantee right now that Uncharted 3 will be a better game than Uncharted 2 but score worse on meta. Reviewers put too much weight on evolution and "moving the bar" to actually concentrate on the main factor which is if the game is actually fun imo.
It doesn't matter to me as I don't care about the scores and always read the text of a review but every time these AAA titles are released I dream of the day someone actually removes the stupid overall score from reviews.