if i did, i might feel compelled to deduct points for some things like poor animations..
Poor animations? I still find the animation of Aggro the best "horse animation" to date.
On topic, I agree with the general sentiment of this thread.
To summarize my opinion, I believe it is the "best" game, ever. It really provides an experience I can't say any other game I've played has duplicated or surpassed.
I'll hopefully be writing a review shortly, if time permits.