*Wii fanboy hat on*
All-Play games are superior in all regards to 360/PS3 versions. Also, due to the rock bottom cost of development on the Wii, All-Play games should be priced around $19.99, new, in the future.
Don't ever go back. You should get the football and basketball attachments for your Wiimote, for the full experience.
*hat off*
Honestly, Tiger Woods is it, due to the nature of the controls. The other All-Play games don't really come close, since there isn't really a natural match for the motion controller in the gameplay, unlike golf. If there was an All-Play baseball game, it might end up decent, however.