andamanen on 08 August 2007
Revies mostly are the opinion of just one person. You can't expect everyone to give it the exact numerical score you think it deserves. Read the reviews, don't just look at the number at the end, that way you really learn a game's strong and weak points.
For this particular case, listen to the latest EGM podcast to hear some of the opinions of the other people who played it and how they liked it (the reviewer of this 1up review is there as well).
http://www.1up.com/do/feature?cId=3149975
