Thats fine, i really tried to get into the game, i managed to get 34 stars before i gave up on the game.  I even went back to the game and i could not get into it.  I really like the  2D mario's, i just could not stand SMG.  I just wish they would make another Mario game for the DS, but i bet it won't happen

Seriously leave well enough, your thread title is on point but your post isn't.

The game is whatever, leave it be and let the PS360 guys go bantering about their resolutions
and polygons.

This thread isn't lol hence it has killed a kitty.

I was responding to Lord's post criticizing my acceptance of another's opinion that this was just another thread created by a likely Nintendo fanboy. However, if the topic is exactly the same as 5 other threads, there's no need for another. I was equally annoyed by the multiple "PS3 is lower resolution but looks better" threads.

 I'll give it's likely he's a Nintendo fanboy, as I stated, but who is leading this backlash is irrelevant. It was coming anyway, and the Sony and Xbox fanboys will join in once the luster wears off. It's just the nature of whiners.

If you are only going to complain about the millions repost topics that annoy you then I am going to critisize you for it. There were at least twice as many topics praising GTA4 then there are now critisizing it. If you want to whine that people are blasting something you like then go ahead but I will point out how you are being dumb about it.

Fine, if they can indentify 1 flaw the performance doesn't get a 10. Doesn't mean it was truly perfect. Anyway, the systems are different. I know what rotten tomatoes does, I described it. However, metacritic also has 3 movies 99% and better, with 1 being 100%. The Godfather might be one of the greatest movies ever, but it's not without flaws. When you are judging entertainment, I don't think perfect score has to mean something is flawless. Movies and games are judged similarly. Throw in music, as well.

Yes, as if anyone would admit they're a fanboy. Either way your prominance in this thread is proof enough of what not to encourage whether the word "fanboy" can be applied  or not.

Though you need look no further than your pitiful hair splitting arguments over game reviews to see the merit of such a claim.

This game does deserve 10/10. Not because it is perfect, but because it blows nearly every single other game out of the water. It may have a few flaws, but they are more than made up for by the good points. Everyone agrees that SA was amazing, a 9.5, at least, and this is better in every way.
1. Better graphics
2. Less pop-up
3. Liberty City is amazing
4. MUCH BETTER GAMEPLAY
5. Cell phone

I think those things are enough to get the game 10/10, as all it is lacking from SA is countryside, aircraft, other little side missions like paramedic

Heh. You are as ridiculous as this thread's topic. I'm posting in this thread because I have nothing better to do right now. Same as you, it would seem. Edit: my comments on what I think game reviews should mean sure has a lot more usefullness than your constant need to single me out in threads without adding anything to it. I love you, though.

There you have it.