91

User predictions:

zombie9ers 93
taus90 91
melbye 97
qwark 92
errorist76 89
pachofilauri 90
train wreck 88
coktoe 90
random_matt 87
dr.vita 91
mummelmann 90
oneeee-chan!!! 93
manuelogando40 85
barkley 86
jranation 91

15 votes total - average score prediction: 90.2

I'll go with 91.

I'm gonna go with an 87.

Knowing Insomniac's track record, it will probably get a much higher metascore.

Going buy insomniacs record on metacritic, somewhere in the mid to late 80s seems likely. I'll go with 87.

Spiderman 2 only got an 80 on metacritic. 

I honestly think this can score a 90+ rateing.

This will easily get 97-96. I'm dead serious.

88. Insomniac makes good games and 88 is surely a good game.

I have a tendency to underrate Spider-Man for some reason. I'll go with high 80s so probably 87.